Effectiveness

vs. CBT



 

Messer, Stanley B. (2004). Evidence-based practice: Beyond empirically supported treatments. Professional Psychology 35(6) 580-588

Excerpts:

...Traditional measures of therapy outcome are neither penetrating enough nor specific enough to individual cases to yield a sufficiently nuanced picture of what has changed or why

The superiority of CBT turned out to be an artifact of including non-bona fide therapies in the comparisons (e.g.supportive counseling). In other words, CBT was not significantly more beneficial than noncognitive and nonbehavioral treatments that were intended to be therapeutic rather than merely serving as a convenient control group for researchers' favored therapy.

Visit abstract on APA PsycNet



 

Hill, Clara E. Chui, Harold and Baumann, Ellen (2013).  Revisiting and revisioning the outcome problem in psychothearpy: An argument to inlcude individualized and qualitative measurement. Psychotherapy Vol.50 (1) p 68-76.

Excerpts

…psychoanalysts are still struggling to make their views heard about the importance of personality and intrapsychic change,  In particular, changes in personality are complex and hard to operationalize and quantify,  Those at the behavioral end of the spectrum, in contrast, care primarily about easily observable changes in symptomatology.

The satisfied CBT clients reported gains in the ability to apply techniques to cope with problems, had taken more control of their lives, and felt their problems were normalized.  In contrast the PDT (Psychodynamic Therapy)  clients reported understanding themselves more, being more able to set limits and boundaries, and having changed the ways in which they relate to others.  Thus, although quantitative measures, as usual, showed few differences between therapies, qualitative analyses showed more theory-predicted results.

Visit abstract at APA PsychNet



 

Castonguay, Louis G. (2013). Psychotherapy Outcome: An issue worth re-revisiting 50 years later. Psychotherapy 50 (1) 52-67

Excerpt: 

...  what has been linked with outcome in CBT are “heretic” interventions such as: fostering emotional experiencing and expression, exploiting attachment relationships with early significant others that include the explorations of the therapeutic relationship and defensive maneuvers.

Visit the abstract at APA PsychNet